Auckland's state houses, 1930s to 1950s: design, materials, ageing
No other group of houses in Auckland was built so deliberately, to so few patterns, in so short a time, as the state houses of the 1930s and 1940s. They were meant to fix a housing shortage and to give work to builders and manufacturers, and they ended up redrawing the map of the city. Some of them are now ninety years old, and the oldest are being replaced.
Why the state built houses
The 1920s had been a decade of private building, much of it financed by cheap state loans. Te Ara's account of housing and government says that the Depression burst the suburban housing bubble: lenders foreclosed on mortgage defaulters, new building stood still, and overcrowding in the main cities became acute. The Labour government elected in 1935 blamed the shortage on market failure and argued that only the state could fix it. In 1936 it drew up plans to use private enterprise to build 5,000 state rental houses, with a new Department of Housing Construction overseeing the work.
The scheme had several aims at once: to give the jobless a trade, boost manufacturing industries, raise housing standards and give tenants security of tenure. Te Ara says the programme was aimed at low- to middle-income families, and that rents were set on a cost-recovery basis, which priced the houses beyond the reach of the poor.
The first state house opened in September 1937 in Miramar, Wellington, and the opening, when Prime Minister Michael Joseph Savage carried a dining table through the front door, became one of the country's iconic photographs, as NZ History records.
Auckland's state suburbs
In Auckland, state housing began at Ōrākei in 1937. Te Ara's suburbs story calls Ōrākei the centrepiece of the first Labour government's state housing plan in Auckland, designed as a garden suburb with curving streets, large green areas and sea views, an exception in a country where suburban growth was typically hasty, economical and practical. By March 1939, Te Ara says, 5,000 state houses had been built nationally, mostly at Miramar, in the Hutt Valley and at Ōrākei.
Auckland Council's history of the city's urban form lists the sequence that followed. State houses were first established at a model estate in Ōrākei in 1937, and continued at increasing scale in Meadowbank in 1939, Waterview from 1944 to 1947 and Mount Roskill in 1945. The council notes that the main focus of the programme was single-unit suburban homes, considered more suitable for families, with some inner-city apartment blocks in the 1940s on Symonds Street and Greys Avenue.
After the war the pace picked up. Kāinga Ora's history says the government built 10,000 state houses a year after the Second World War, planning entire suburbs with shops, amenities and landscaped public spaces. In the 1950s, high-density state housing developments appeared in South Auckland, and Auckland Council's history says that by the early 1970s state houses made up over 40 per cent of the housing in Ōtara, with more than 5,000 built there by 1983.
What a state house looked like
The standard house was a simple detached three-bedroom family home. Te Ara describes how new building materials, power tools and construction techniques meant firms such as Fletchers could mass-produce houses cheaply and quickly, and the simple three-bedroom detached house became the standard for both state and private suburbs. Te Ara's building industry story describes them as simple weatherboard or brick houses built by large firms and small building contractors.
The look was English cottage. According to Te Ara, that style became synonymous with the 1930s Labour government's state-housing scheme, and the houses are still recognised by their 45-degree-pitch tiled roofs and three-pane casement windows. Te Ara's summary of the styles adds that state houses were built facing the sun.
Variety was designed in. Kāinga Ora says that by 1939 more than 5,000 state houses had been built, using 400 different architectural designs so that no two homes would look identical. The state also sometimes economised: Te Ara notes that as the cost of the programme grew the state began building cheaper, one-storey semi-detached houses disguised to look like detached dwellings, often with an asymmetrical elevation, and that wooden terrace housing was built under state schemes in the 1950s and 1960s to reduce costs.
Inside, the change from earlier houses was in the services. Te Ara's illustration of suburban housing notes that by the time of the English-cottage-style state house, built in thousands in new suburbs after the Second World War, the bathroom, toilet and washhouse had come inside.
Materials and shortages
Timber was the main material, as it had been for the villa, but the details of supply changed with the decade. After the war, Kāinga Ora records, 500 pre-cut houses were imported from Austria to address material shortages. The group building scheme, in which the government subsidised developers who built houses to government designs, produced multi-unit buildings made from cheaper materials like fibrolite, which Kāinga Ora says lacked privacy.
Te Ara lists fibrolite as an asbestos product and notes that fibrolite fell from favour in the 1970s when it was discovered that asbestos fibres are carcinogenic, and that plasterboard had by then replaced scrim as the usual interior lining. A BRANZ article on renovating character homes warns that old cement-based sheet linings sometimes contain asbestos and that testing, removal and working with it should follow WorkSafe guidance and be done by trained, licensed professionals. That article was written about villas and bungalows, but the caution applies equally to mid-century houses with similar linings.
How they have aged
Each decade of state houses ages in its own way, but several features recur across the group.
- Insulation. Te Ara says that timber-frame houses gave little insulation beyond weatherboards and linings, which made for freezing and damp interiors in winter. New houses have had to include insulation in ceilings and walls since the 1970s, and in 2009 the government introduced subsidies to insulate older houses.
- Linings and cladding. Fibrolite and other fibre-cement products from the mid-century can contain asbestos. A house that has been altered over the years may carry a mix of original and later materials, so any renovation should start by finding out what is actually there.
- Foundations. Houses from this era are likely to stand on concrete or treated timber piles, since BRANZ says those are likely in houses built since 1930, and BRANZ advises that older piled houses without subfloor bracing can be vulnerable in earthquakes.
- Roofs. BRANZ says of period tile roofs that they have a finite life and the tiles are usually at a similar level of deterioration, so when some begin failing the rest are often not far behind. The same holds for the tiled roofs that gave state houses their profile.
Renewal
The oldest Auckland state houses are now being replaced. Kāinga Ora says that the first Auckland state house was built in Ōrākei in 1937 and that many of these older properties now need to be replaced with warm, dry homes better suited to current and future needs. With a local advisory group and its partner Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei, it has developed a neighbourhood plan to renew and replace the older houses over seven to ten years.
For those state houses that remain in private hands, now sold to tenants under the policy introduced by the National government in the early 1950s, the sensible approach is the one that applies to any older house: find out what the building is made of, dry out the subfloor, insulate, and check linings before cutting into them.
Sources
- Te Ara: Housing and government, State loans and state houses
- Te Ara: Suburbs, The state builds suburbs; Housing, Housing types; Housing, Style and form; Housing, Construction and materials; Types of suburban housing
- Te Ara: Building and construction industry, Residential construction companies
- NZ History: The first state house
- Kāinga Ora: History of state housing and Long term renewal plan for Ōrākei
- Auckland Council: A brief history of Auckland's urban form (2019)
- BRANZ: Getting down to it, Keeping in character and Upgrading piled foundations to resist earthquakes (Bulletin 536)