Why paint fails on old weatherboards, and what it tells you
A paint film that has gone wrong is not just an eyesore. It is the house reporting on itself. Where the paint fails, how it fails and when it fails usually point to a cause, and the cause matters more than the colour of the next coat. Painting over a symptom is the surest way to repeat the problem in three years.
Paint is a weather barrier, not decoration
On a timber villa, the paint is doing real work. BRANZ's guidance on horizontal timber weatherboards says the most common cause of timber deterioration is failure of the protective paint coating, which lets the boards get wet and stay wet, and that ultimately causes rotting. It lists several reasons for failure: paintwork exceeding its serviceable life, poor preparation before painting, an incorrect paint system for the situation, and timber or fixings that have corroded.
Boards add their own complication. BRANZ points out that timber is hygroscopic, meaning that it takes up moisture from the air, so the boards move with changes in moisture content, and that paint and stain finishes on weatherboards need regular recoating. A film that cannot flex with that movement cracks, and cracks let water in.
Moisture: the usual suspect
An extension-service guide from Purdue University calls moisture the most common cause of premature paint failure on wood. It separates the sources, and each tells you something.
- Water from outside concentrates at board ends, joints and edges, and on the sides taking most of the wind-driven rain. Failure that clusters there is pointing to water entering from outside.
- Water vapour from inside comes from cooking, bathing, drying clothes, unvented heaters and damp crawl spaces. It passes through the wall, condenses in cold weather and soaks the siding. The guide suggests that failure worse in winter, or near bathrooms, kitchens and laundries, is a hint of vapour from inside.
- Liquid water from inside, such as a leaking pipe or an overflow, produces damage that is not seasonal and appears when a fault develops.
In an Auckland villa, the corollary is to look behind the paint. Failure under a bathroom window or along the wall that shares the laundry may have little to do with the paint product and a lot to do with the room on the other side. BRANZ adds a related list of causes that let water into the timber itself: split boards from double nailing, nails popping, failed joints at mitred corners, and corroded fixings or flashings.
Blistering
Blisters come in two varieties, according to the Purdue guide. Temperature blisters form within a day or two of painting, only in the last coat, when solvent vapour trapped under a dry skin expands as the sun heats fresh paint. They are mostly seen with oil-based paint, dark colours and thick coats, and they point to painting in direct sun or at the wrong time of day.
Moisture blisters are different. They contain water, extend down to bare wood, and tend to appear at joints and end grain or after wet weather. If they appear at no particular season, the guide suggests an inside leak.
Peeling, flaking and cracking
Peeling comes in at least two types. If a new coat separates from an old one, usually within a year of repainting, the likely culprit is a weak bond: inadequate cleaning of weathered paint, chalky residue, or a delay of more than two weeks between an oil-based primer and the topcoat. The guide suggests a tape test, in which paint transferring to the tape means the old surface is too chalky and needs more cleaning or an oil-based primer.
If the paint peels right down to bare wood, the story is usually water entering through the paint or the wood, as above. BRANZ's advice for this case is to scrape and sand off flaking paint where the timber is sound, wash, and prime all exposed timber before repainting, or to strip back to bare timber where the paintwork is poor throughout.
A house that has been repainted many times may crack across the grain in the direction of the brush strokes. Purdue says this is caused by excessively thick paint build-up, common on older homes, and that once it happens the only fix is complete removal of the old paint. BRANZ also notes fine cracking of paint at board laps, which it ascribes to timber movement, as a problem that is not necessarily about weathertightness but does affect the finish.
Chalking and fading
A chalky surface means that the paint binder is wearing away, leaving pigment as a powder. The Purdue guide describes chalking as part of normal weathering, with paint gradually eroding on the sides most exposed to the sun and rain, so even finish on a sunny wall is no cause for alarm. The significant point is what chalk does to the next coat. If chalk stops new paint bonding, which the tape test will show, the surface needs cleaning before repainting.
BRANZ lists fading and chalking of paint, especially where dark colours are used, as an appearance issue that does not itself affect weathertightness, together with differential weathering between exposed and sheltered areas and resin bleed through the paint.
Incompatible coats and the wrong system
Not every failure is a moisture problem. The Purdue guide recommends an oil-based or stain-blocking primer under acrylic latex topcoats, warns about the timing between primer and topcoat, and says that new, thin oil-based coats are the most prone to moisture blisters. BRANZ's reference to an incorrect paint system being used for the situation is the general version of the same idea. For an old house, that means finding out what is on the walls before choosing what goes on top. Owners who want a second opinion on peeling, blistering and chalking paint on their own boards can use a painter's assessment alongside the pattern-reading above.
Using the pattern to decide what to do
A rough guide to the pattern might look like this.
- Failure on one side or in patches near joints or end grain: look for water getting in, then repair joints and flashings before repainting.
- Failure near wet rooms or on one wall: check ventilation and leaks inside.
- Even, widespread chalking: wash, test with tape, and repaint with a suitable primer.
- Thick, cracked old coats: plan for removal rather than another layer.
BRANZ suggests a screwdriver check for rot: if it goes into the timber easily, the timber is rotten, and the rotted section should be cut out and the framing behind it checked. Only once the boards are sound and dry, with fixings and joints repaired, is repainting worthwhile. Auckland firms such as Eggshell & Co publish their own guidance on these paint problems, which is worth reading before agreeing a scope of work.
Sources
- BRANZ: Horizontal timber weatherboards
- Purdue University Extension: Causes of exterior paint failure on wood (NCR-133)