Brick chimneys in older houses: the earthquake risk and your options
The brick chimney is one of the great sights of the older New Zealand street, a solid red stack rising from the ridge of a villa. It is also, on the Natural Hazards Commission's reckoning, one of the most common hazards in the country's older houses. Te Ara notes that the most common use of brick in houses was in chimneys, and that right through to the 1950s it was customary to have fireplaces in main living rooms and kitchens, and often in bedrooms. Many of those chimneys are still standing, and many are no longer used.
Why chimneys fail
Te Ara's building materials story observes that brick and stone withstood fire but not earthquakes, which is why brick veneer over a timber frame developed as a compromise. A chimney is the part of the old house that never made that compromise.
The Natural Hazards Commission (formerly the Earthquake Commission) says that when the ground shakes, older unreinforced brick and concrete masonry chimneys can cause serious damage to homes and harm to people. Chimneys can be the heaviest part of a timber-framed house, weighing hundreds of kilos, and may topple or collapse through the roof or fall outwards onto your property or a neighbour's. The Commission says thousands of hazardous chimneys exist around the country and many owners are unaware of the danger. Its page on hazardous chimneys is the main reference for this article.
The history supports the warning. In a separate news item, the Commission recalls the 1855 Wairarapa earthquake, in which thousands of chimneys collapsed or caused damage, and one of the few fatalities was attributed to a brick chimney collapsing into the room where the person was sitting. It also says numerous insurance claims after the 2010-11 Canterbury earthquakes were because unreinforced chimneys fell and damaged properties.
Assessing yours
The Commission's guidance runs as follows.
- Age. Chimneys built before 1970 pose the greatest risk because they are less likely to have extra internal reinforcement, and older chimneys are more likely to have deteriorated mortar. Brick chimneys built after 1985 should have a reinforced concrete flue inside the brickwork and be tied to the house framing. A quick inspection by a licensed building practitioner should confirm whether yours is reinforced.
- Records. The LIM report or council property file may give more information on the age of the house.
- Signs of damage. Look for cracks in the brick or mortar, a lean or twist in the structure, and loose, missing or broken bricks. Check also whether the chimney is connected to the house with steel strapping at each storey and to the roof.
If you see any of these, the Commission advises contacting a licensed building practitioner. For owners who decide to go into or onto the roof to check, it points to WorkSafe's guidance on working safely there.
Options, from lightest to heaviest
The right choice depends on whether the fireplace is still in use.
Remove the whole chimney. If the fireplace is no longer used, taking everything out, from above the roofline right down to floor level, removes the risk entirely. The Commission calls it the safest option, and also a significant piece of work and the most expensive. Demolition should be done by a professional.
Remove or replace the part above the roof. The most hazardous part is the section above the roofline, so removing just that is a sensible middle course, usually cheaper and quicker than removing the whole chimney when the fireplace is disused. If the fire is still in use, the top can be replaced with a lightweight metal flue, which can be installed at the same time as a solid fuel heater without replacing the existing firebox.
Strengthen it. If removal is not possible straight away, the Commission suggests plywood bracing in the roof space to stop falling bricks entering the house, and restraints or straps that anchor the chimney to the house. The strapping needed depends on the chimney's size.
Keep the look. Where a council wants the visual character retained, or you simply like the chimney, the Commission notes that faux chimneys replicate the original appearance while cutting weight, and lightweight flues can be made to resemble brick.
Consent, character and who does the work
The Commission says to check with your council before removing a chimney, because there may be requirements for character or heritage homes. In an Auckland Special Character Area, external alterations to a building are restricted discretionary activities under the Unitary Plan, while repair is permitted. That suggests the council should be asked before a visible chimney comes down, even though the plan does not mention chimneys by name.
On the building side, Schedule 1 of the Building Act 2004 exempts the removal of a building element from a building of no more than three storeys, provided the removal does not affect the primary structure, a specified system or fire separation. A chimney tied into framing, or sitting on a wall, may well raise those questions, so ask the council or a licensed practitioner whether a given removal needs consent. The Commission's advice is to use a licensed building practitioner for restricted building work.
Buying a house with a chimney
If you are buying an older house, the chimney deserves a question. The Commission's age bands are a good starting point, and an inspector can look for the signs above. Removing or bracing a chimney costs money and has to be sequenced with the roof and any interior work, so it is best known about before the offer, not after.