Buying a do-up in Auckland: questions for the building report and LIM
A do-up has a particular charm. The bones are good, the timber is old and the price leaves room for a renovation. It also has a particular risk: more of what matters sits behind the linings, under the floor and in the council's files than in the listing photographs. The paperwork you collect before making an offer is how you find out what sort of do-up you are being offered.
This article sets out what the main documents are, what they can and cannot tell you, and the questions that older timber houses tend to raise. It is general information drawn from Consumer Protection guidance, and your lawyer should read the documents alongside you.
The building report: useful, but limited
Consumer Protection recommends an independent pre-purchase inspection, and warns that skimping on one is risky. The standard version is a Residential Property Inspection under NZS 4306:2005, which is a visual inspection. It will not identify problems concealed behind finished surfaces, such as plumbing, framing, insulation or wiring. The inspector looks for signs of borer, rot, damp, structural damage, drainage issues, wiring and pipes, photographs problem areas and comments on them.
Several practical points follow from the guidance in Consumer Protection's building reports page.
- A report from the vendor is not your report. The vendor is the client, so you are unlikely to have any recourse if it misses something. A buyer's own inspection can flag issues the vendor's report leaves out.
- Check the inspector. Ask that they can do a NZS 4306 inspection, and ask to see proof of indemnity insurance. Consumer Protection suggests members of the Building Officials Institute or the NZ Institute of Building Inspectors, and says to think twice about using an ex-builder mate.
- Go along if you can. Some inspectors are happy for the buyer to attend, which lets you see issues first-hand, though it may cost slightly more.
- Ask for a specialist if you suspect something specific, such as earthquake damage, natural hazard vulnerability, a leaky home or a boundary question. A registered building surveyor can say what kind of inspection is right, and may refer you to an engineer.
- Follow up the findings. Ask what could happen if a problem is left, and how urgently it needs fixing, and get a builder's estimate of repair costs so you can decide what to fix, what to negotiate and when to walk away.
The consent gap
One line in the guidance matters more than most for a do-up. A pre-purchase inspection may identify where work has been done on the original house, such as a dug-out basement, a new room or a deck, but it will not tell you whether those renovations had building consent. That must be found from council records and the LIM report.
The consequence can be serious. Consumer Protection's worked example describes buyers whose inspection suggested a toilet had been moved. The LIM showed no consent, and the buyers knew that could cause problems with insurance. They asked the council what would be needed to get the work signed off, found it was more than they wanted to take on, and kept looking.
The LIM and the council file
Consumer Protection's guide to preparing an offer describes the LIM, or land information memorandum, as a summary of the current information the council has on the property, including flood and erosion risks, rates, and consents and permits granted by the council, such as a building consent for a bathroom or a deck above a certain height. It suggests that your lawyer read the LIM alongside the council files to spot discrepancies, such as missing consent applications.
Council files hold things that are not in the LIM, including site plans showing where buildings sit in relation to the boundary, and the original plans. The guidance suggests comparing the consents in the LIM with the original floor plan, the current size and the state of the house: are all the rooms where the plan puts them, and have any rooms been added? If you can, take the file to a viewing. It also says council files can be cheaper than LIM reports and are sometimes more important.
Questions that older houses raise
These are prompts, not a checklist from a regulator.
- What has been altered, and where is the consent? Compare the LIM with what you can see. Note anything that does not appear in the records.
- What are the exterior walls clad in, and is it original? Consumer Protection's red flags include weatherside, a weatherboard it says is known to leak, in houses built in the early 1980s, and plaster-style monolithic cladding used from the 1980s to the mid-2000s. For a villa, a bigger question is the condition of the boards and paint. BRANZ's weatherboard guidance says failure of the paint coat is the commonest cause of rot.
- Is there asbestos? Consumer Protection says asbestos was used widely from the mid-1940s to the mid-1980s and can be on ceilings, roofs, under lino and in fences. WorkSafe says homes built before 1 January 2000 may contain some. If any is found, get specialist advice on risk, removal, time and cost.
- Is there lead paint? Health NZ says to presume lead-based paint in any building from the 1980s or earlier, which includes every villa and bungalow. It shapes how you budget and plan any scraping or sanding.
- What are the walls lined with? Scrim and sarking, BRANZ says, is an extreme fire risk, and most house insurers will require its removal. Ask about insurance before you commit.
- What does the chimney look like? The Natural Hazards Commission says the LIM or property file can help establish a home's age, and that chimneys built before 1970 pose the greatest risk.
- Is the house in a special character area or other overlay? That affects what you can do to the outside once you own it.
- What is the plumbing? The red flags list black plastic piping, known to leak and unlikely to be covered by insurers if you knew it was there, for houses built or re-plumbed around the late 1970s to early 1980s.
Sequence and insurance
Consumer Protection notes that most banks and lenders will not confirm a loan until insurance is in place, and that a lender may ask for the building report. If you have any older house in your sights, it is sensible to approach an insurer early and ask what they want to know.
Make your offer conditional on the reports being satisfactory to you, and ask your lawyer or conveyancer to check the sale and purchase agreement before you sign. Consumer Protection says not to sign until they have.
Sources
- Consumer Protection, Building reports and red flags
- Consumer Protection, Prepare to make an offer
- BRANZ, Getting down to it
- BRANZ, Horizontal timber weatherboards
- WorkSafe, Asbestos in the home quick guide (council-hosted copy)
- Natural Hazards Commission, Hazardous chimneys
- Health NZ, Lead-based paint