Piles and subfloors in old Auckland houses
A villa looks as if it grew out of its section, but it is actually standing on a few dozen posts. Under the floor, out of sight and mostly out of mind, a grid of piles carries the bearers, which carry the joists, which carry the floorboards. When something goes wrong down there, the signs show up upstairs: a sloping hall, a door that sticks, a floor that bounces under a heavy step.
What the piles were made of
BRANZ's guidance on keeping the character of older homes says that almost all early villas and bungalows were built on native timber piles, often tōtara or pūriri. After a century or so, many of these have deteriorated. Some look sound at ground level while having rotted away entirely below it, which is the reason an examination from above alone can mislead.
Later repairs and replacements change the picture. The same BRANZ article notes that replacement treated pine piles or precast concrete piles may be present, and that early in-situ concrete piles can still be found cast in kerosene tins, roughly 300 mm square, with the rusting remains of the tin left as permanent formwork. Concrete pads are sometimes found too, usually redundant, where a washhouse copper or an open fireplace once stood. BRANZ Bulletin 536 says that houses on pile foundations built since 1930 are likely to have concrete or treated timber piles.
Some of the later bungalows also have reinforced concrete perimeter foundation walls, which BRANZ says an experienced repiling contractor will include in an assessment along with the piles and subfloor framing.
Signs the foundations are moving
Upstairs, BRANZ points to two early indicators: a noticeable slope to the floor, usually pointing to differential settlement, and springiness underfoot. Either can mean pile settlement or failure, or rot in bearers and joists. Most issues of site settlement, BRANZ adds, trace back to water, such as leaking pipes or drains, and old earthenware drains do not last forever.
What an owner can check underneath
A torch, old clothes and a kneeling mat are the toolkit. Few villas offer generous headroom, so some owners will prefer to leave the crawl to a professional, but the checks themselves are simple.
- Pile connections. Bulletin 536 describes the usual fixing between a pile and a bearer as 4 mm galvanised wire stapled to both, or wire dogs and skewed nails. If the house is more than 30 years old, or has a damp, poorly ventilated subfloor, these fixings may have rusted badly or away. BRANZ, in a separate article on pre-1978 houses, says many connections are badly corroded and many piles are simply disconnected from the floor framing.
- Pile height and lean. Under severe earthquake loading, the bulletin says, tall piles may tilt over unless they are braced or built very close to the ground, with a maximum of 200 mm to the underside of the bearers.
- The state of the ground. BRANZ suggests rubbing a handful of soil from under the house into your hand. If it stains like mud, the subfloor probably holds too much moisture. Vents blocked by garden soil or planting, stored timber, and water running under the house after rain are the usual culprits.
- Vents. BRANZ's subfloor ventilation guidance gives 3,500 mm² of opening per square metre of floor as the NZS 3604:2011 figure and a good target for existing houses, noting that it applies to new construction.
- Leaks and fungi. BRANZ's ventilation article shows fungal growth beneath a leaking wastepipe in one house, a reminder to trace any plumbing under the floor and look for damp patches or growth on the timber around it.
Borer and the subfloor
The subfloor is also where wood-boring beetles concentrate. Scion's fact sheet on the two-toothed longhorn notes that untreated rimu used for subflooring, bearers, joists and jack studs in damp, poorly ventilated places is often severely damaged. If you are curious about how borer in piles and subfloors usually shows up, a page on borer in piles and subfloors covers the typical signs under a house of this type, and the point to remember is that a dry, ventilated space is the best deterrent either way.
Repiling and bracing
When piles have failed, BRANZ recommends engaging an experienced repiling contractor. They have the people, equipment and know-how to jack up the house, evaluate piles, bearers and joists, replace what needs replacing and level the whole building at the same time. BRANZ stresses the value of that last step: a level platform is crucial for the long-term success of later renovation work.
Seismic upgrading is often done alongside. Bulletin 536 explains that older houses with piled foundations and no subfloor bracing can be particularly vulnerable in earthquakes. Options include replacing pile-to-bearer connections, bracing piles and jack studs, and fixing sheet bracing around the perimeter. Where there is more than 600 mm between ground and joists, the bulletin describes fixing fibre-cement or plywood sheet bracing to the piles; for houses with all shallow piles, it advises seeking specialist advice. BRANZ notes that piles going only 100 to 150 mm below the ground may not give a brace enough resistance, and that an upgrade becoming an alteration may need a building consent, so check with the council first.
Consumer NZ records that for new piles the Building Code Acceptable Solution requires timber treated to at least H5.
Making the new subfloor drier
A repile is a convenient time to deal with moisture. BRANZ suggests laying polythene over the bare earth, taped around each pile, so that evaporation from the ground stays out of the timber structure. It says the building then reaches a new equilibrium of lower moisture content, usually after about a year. It also recommends making sure the void is well ventilated, and notes that if a building is lifted for repiling it can sometimes be reinstated slightly higher, provided you check height limits and recession planes with the council.
BRANZ's first suggestion for a damp subfloor is to clear out obstructions such as stored timber and rubbish. A specialist inspection, such as one from Lignum Timber Inspections, can establish whether any borer present is active and how far it extends before a repile decision is made.
Sources
- BRANZ: Keeping in character
- BRANZ: Strengthening piled foundations
- BRANZ: Bulletin 536, Upgrading piled foundations to resist earthquakes
- BRANZ: Subfloor ventilation
- Scion (via NZ Farm Forestry Association): Two-toothed longhorn, Ambeodontus tristis
- Consumer NZ: Borer and other pests