Insulating an old villa or bungalow: ceiling, floor and walls
The builders of Auckland's villas and bungalows had the best timber to hand and were not planning for a heat pump. Their houses stand on piles with board floors above open ground, and many are lined with scrim and sarking, which is a poor insulator. The government's building guidance puts the result plainly: many old homes, especially those built before 1978, have little or no insulation, which makes them uncomfortable, expensive to heat and less healthy.
The remedy is usually staged. Some parts of the house are easy and rewarding to insulate; others are best left until the walls are opened up for other reasons. The order below follows the Ministry's own advice.
Start overhead
Ceilings are, according to the Building Performance guide to insulating existing homes, often the easiest and most effective area to insulate. If the roof space is accessible, bulk insulation can simply be laid over the ceiling lining and framing.
A few points from the guide:
- Existing insulation may have settled or been disturbed. As a rough rule of thumb, if it is no longer thicker than the framing, about 120 mm, it is probably worth adding more. Look for gaps, too, since even small uncovered areas lose heat.
- If the existing material is dry and free of rodents it can usually stay, with a new layer on top.
- Old downlights and some other electrical equipment may need a clear gap for fire safety, so do not bury them.
- In most situations a 25 mm gap should be kept between insulation and the roofing underlay, because poorly installed insulation can cause moisture problems.
- Ceilings without a usable roof space are difficult. The best moment is when the lining or roofing is being replaced.
Turn off the power supply to the house before working in the ceiling or under the floor. The guidance says so, and it is not a formality.
Then the floor
For a timber floor on piles, which is the villa and bungalow standard, the guide describes uninsulated suspended floors as a major source of unnecessary heat loss and discomfort. If the space under the floor is accessible and high enough, insulation can go between the joists, most commonly bulk fibre or polystyrene.
Two cautions apply to older houses.
Old foil. Many old houses were previously insulated with aluminium foil. The guide says the foil does not provide enough insulation and, in contact with electric wiring, can become a serious hazard. Retrofitting or repairing foil insulation is now banned, so the only option is to replace it with modern bulk insulation, with the power off and an electrician's help if anything is unclear.
Ground moisture. If the subfloor is enclosed, a polythene ground sheet reduces moisture entering the house and helps the insulation work better. If you cannot get under the floor at all, a good time to insulate is when the floor is being changed, for instance when re-piling or replacing boards.
Walls come last, and carefully
The Ministry's guide says that in most cases it is not easy to retrofit insulation in existing walls, and a building consent is usually required (or specific approval from the council's building inspector that it is not). This is consistent with Schedule 1 of the Building Act 2004, which exempts installing thermal insulation in an existing building except in an external wall or a fire separation wall. It also exempts laying a ground moisture barrier in the subfloor.
The most effective moment, says the guide, is when the cladding or the lining is being replaced. If there is no building paper, it should be installed at the same time to stop moisture wicking into the insulation and lining. Products that are blown into the cavity through drilled holes exist, and if you are considering one, the guide advises hiring a registered or accredited building surveyor to confirm the cladding is weathertight and whether there is underlay behind it.
For houses with scrim-and-sarking linings, BRANZ gives a fuller account in its renovation series. It says scrim and wallpaper should be removed because of fire risk, that the sarking can come off too to give access to the wall cavities, and that this is a chance for an electrician to check the wiring and for new building wrap, which is almost always needed because the old paper has usually broken down. It recommends checking that wall framing moisture content is no more than 18 per cent before closing up, and notes that it is a good moment to create a bracing panel using proprietary hold-down brackets and a bracing-rated plasterboard lining. The article also warns that old cement-based sheet linings sometimes contain asbestos: follow WorkSafe's guidance on testing and removal, and use trained and licensed professionals. These points are in BRANZ's Getting down to it.
Windows are the weak point
Whatever else you do, single glazing remains the biggest leak. The Ministry's guide puts the insulation value of single glazing at about one-twentieth of an insulated wall. Its options run from double glazed units, to secondary glazing in acrylic or glass that performs about as well, to inexpensive films that last a winter, to draught strips on old timber frames that no longer close properly.
Check what is in the ceiling before you start
An old ceiling may hold more than old insulation. WorkSafe's guidance on asbestos in the home lists insulation in roof cavities, around hot water pipes and in fireplaces as places where asbestos has been used, and says that you cannot tell whether a material contains asbestos by looking at it. Homes built before 1 January 2000 may contain some asbestos. If you find anything suspicious, do not disturb it. The WorkSafe quick guide is hosted here as Asbestos in the home.
A sensible order
- Ceiling first, once the electrics and any asbestos question are settled.
- Underfloor second, with a ground sheet if the subfloor is enclosed and foil removed if present.
- Windows and draught-stopping, room by room, starting with the ones you use.
- Walls when you are re-lining or re-cladding anyway.
Seen that way, insulating an old house is less a single project than a sequence that follows the house's own maintenance cycle.