Repairs without a building consent: what Schedule 1 allows
An old house is always asking for something: a board here, a sill there, a length of spouting, a patch of lining. If every such job needed a council permit, the villas of Auckland would fall down waiting for paperwork. The Building Act 2004 recognises this, and Schedule 1 lists the building work that can go ahead without a building consent. The list is generous, but it is also precise, and the precision is where owners come unstuck.
This article walks through the parts of Schedule 1 that matter most to the owner of an older timber house. It is a guide to reading the schedule, not legal advice, and the council has the last word on a borderline job.
The first rule: the Code still applies
Start with section 17 of the Act, which says that all building work must comply with the building code to the extent required by the Act, whether or not a building consent is required. An exemption removes the consent step. It does not remove the standard the finished work must meet. A repair that skips the paperwork but lets water into the wall is still a defective repair, and it is still yours to put right.
Everything below sits under that rule. You can read the full text, including the amendments, on the NZ Legislation site.
Clause 1: repair, maintenance and replacement
The workhorse of the schedule is clause 1. In plain terms:
- Repair and maintenance of a building product, or of an assembly that is part of or associated with the building, is exempt, provided that a comparable product or assembly is used.
- Replacement is exempt, provided that a comparable product or assembly is used and the replacement is in the same position.
"Comparable" is the key word, and the schedule leaves it to be applied sensibly. Replacing a rotted weatherboard with a board of similar profile and material in the same spot fits comfortably. Swapping timber cladding for a different system does not look like repair at all.
The limits that catch people
Clause 1 then lists three things that subclauses (1) and (2) do not include.
- Complete or substantial replacement of a specified system. The Act uses that term for particular building systems; a council can tell you whether a job touches one.
- Complete or substantial replacement of a product or assembly that contributes to the building's structural behaviour or fire-safety properties. In an old timber house the framing, bracing and anything doing structural work belongs here.
- Repair or replacement, other than maintenance, of something that has failed the building code's durability requirements. The schedule gives an example: a failure to comply with the external moisture requirements.
That third exclusion deserves attention. If cladding has rotted because it was installed in a way that never met the code's moisture requirements, replacing it is not automatically exempt, even though the work looks like plain repair. Ordinary wear on a house that has been properly maintained is a different matter, but the question of why something failed can decide whether you need consent.
Sanitary plumbing and drainlaying done under the Plumbers, Gasfitters, and Drainlayers Act 2006 is carved out of clause 1 as well, and is dealt with in a separate part of the schedule for people authorised under that Act.
Other exemptions worth knowing
Several other clauses speak directly to old-house work:
- Windows and exterior doorways (clause 8). Building work on a window, including replacing it, or an exterior doorway in an existing dwelling of no more than two storeys is exempt, with two exceptions: replacement of one that has failed the code's durability requirements, and work that modifies or affects a specified system.
- Internal linings and finishes (clause 12). Work on the internal lining or finish of any wall, ceiling or floor of an existing dwelling is exempt.
- Thermal insulation (clause 13). Installing insulation in an existing building is exempt, except in an external wall or in a fire separation wall.
- Ground moisture barrier (clause 13A). Laying a barrier in an existing building's subfloor space is exempt.
- Removal of a building element (clause 31). Taking an element out of a building of no more than three storeys is exempt, provided it does not affect the primary structure, a specified system or any fire separation.
- Demolition of a detached building (clause 30). Complete demolition of a detached building of no more than three storeys is exempt.
- Discretionary exemptions (clause 2). The council may decide that a consent is unnecessary where it considers the completed work is likely to comply with the code, or, if it did not, is unlikely to endanger people or buildings.
The structural flavour of the exceptions repeats throughout: if the work changes the primary structure or a specified system, assume the exemption stops.
Exempt from one rule is not exempt from all of them
Three other layers can still apply.
Resource management rules. A building consent and a resource consent are different things. In an Auckland Special Character Area, for example, restoration and repair are permitted under the Unitary Plan's overlay rules, but external alterations and new buildings need resource consent. A repair that quietly turns into a change of cladding, windows or roof form may be an alteration.
Restricted building work. Some work on a house is restricted building work, which has to be done by a licensed building practitioner. The Natural Hazards Commission's chimney guidance, for one, tells owners to use a licensed practitioner for restricted building work, and the Ministry's building guidance explains which jobs fall within it.
Hazards in old materials. Exempt work can still disturb asbestos or lead paint, and both are governed by their own rules and guidance, quite apart from the Building Act.
A sensible habit
Before a sizeable job, ask three questions.
- Is it repair or replacement with comparable material, in the same place?
- Does it touch the structure, bracing, fire separation or a specified system?
- Did the thing fail because of how it was built, rather than age?
If any answer is uncertain, ring the council and describe the job in writing. A written reply, or a consent, is cheaper than discovering later that a sale is stalled over unrecorded work. And keep photographs and invoices of exempt work: as Consumer Protection points out, a pre-purchase inspection may spot that work has been done but will not tell the buyer whether it had consent, and the paper trail is the best evidence you will have.