Corrugated iron roofs on old houses: rust, repair and re-roofing
Of all the materials on an old New Zealand house, the roof is the one most likely to be called corrugated iron and least likely to be iron. Te Ara points out that it is more correctly steel, galvanised with zinc, and that it was invented in Britain in the 1820s and was available in New Zealand as early as 1843. Strong and cheap, it became the characteristic roof of the country, and the villa's pitched hip and gable looks right wearing it.
Knowing how the roof was put together is the first step in deciding what to do about it when it starts to fail.
A short history of the sheet
Corrugated iron was first made in English mills in the 1830s, according to Te Ara's story on iron and steel, and was at first thought suitable only for temporary buildings. It spread through the goldfields because it was weatherproof, light and quick to put up. The sheets were galvanised, which means coated with zinc, then rolled into corrugations at 3 or 5 inches (76 or 127 millimetres).
From the early twentieth century it was mainly a roofing material, traditionally painted red or green. Many immigrants, Te Ara records, were surprised by the colourful iron roofs when they arrived. It remained the most common roofing material until the 1980s, when aluminium-coated steel such as Zincalume largely replaced it, though Te Ara says only that these are claimed to have better corrosion resistance.
One exception is worth knowing about: most 1930s and 1940s state houses were roofed with concrete or ceramic tiles instead, a policy that favoured local tile manufacturing since New Zealand had a ceramics industry but not a steel one.
Why old roofs fail
Te Ara's building materials story explains one of the weak points in the traditional system. Flashings at junctions were folded from plain galvanised sheet with lead strips attached to the edges so that they could be pressed down into the corrugations, and lead-capped nails were driven through the peaks of the corrugations to hold the roof down, the lead caps stopping water entering the nail holes. Those old fixings are among the first things to wear out on a roof of that age.
The BRANZ Good Repair Guide to profiled metal roofing gives the general picture of why such roofs are replaced. It lists cladding failure due to corrosion, leaks from poor original design or installation, wind or tree damage, the wish to match a newer addition, or the wish to change the appearance. Corrosion, in other words, is only one of several reasons, and sometimes the leaking detail is not the iron at all. The description is on the Building CodeHub entry for the guide.
No official source consulted here puts a single number on how many years an old galvanised roof should last, and it would be wrong to invent one. Condition is a matter for the roof itself, and a roofer or an independent building inspector can judge it in a way no desktop guide can.
Repair or replace?
Some sensible tests, none of them exotic:
- Is the rust on the surface or through the sheet? Surface rust that can be cleaned and repainted is a maintenance job. Holes are not.
- Where is it worst? If the damage is confined to a few sheets or fixings, they may be replaceable without re-roofing the whole house.
- How is the roof fixed? If the fixings are failing broadly, patching becomes false economy.
- What is under the iron? Underlay, battens and the timber roof structure matter as much as the sheets. A re-roof is the moment to inspect them.
- Is the leak really the roof? Gutters, flashings and chimney surrounds are common culprits and cheaper to remedy.
Because of the lead involved, take care with repainting or stripping a roof of this age. Te Ara notes that lead is poisonous and that lead-capped nails and lead-edged flashings are not used on roofs that collect drinking water. If your house takes its drinking water from the roof, tell any roofer, and use a modern substitute for the lead. Old paint on the iron is also likely to contain lead if it dates from before the 1980s, and Health NZ's advice on removing lead-based paint, covering containment, wet methods and not burning debris, applies to roofs as well as walls.
The asbestos question
Not every old roof is iron. WorkSafe's asbestos guidance lists asbestos cement as a common material for roof sheeting and ridge capping, and for gutters, downpipes, eaves linings and the cladding of garages and sheds, and states that you cannot tell if a material contains asbestos just by looking at it. Houses built before 1 January 2000 may contain some. If any roofing, soffit or ridge cap might be cement sheeting, treat it as suspect until a surveyor says otherwise, and do not drill, cut, sand or water-blast it. The guide is hosted by a council as WorkSafe's Asbestos in the home quick guide.
Consent and character
For a like-for-like replacement of the cladding, Schedule 1 of the Building Act 2004 exempts replacement of a building product with a comparable one in the same position, but it excludes work on structural elements and anything that has failed the building code's durability requirements, and the work must still meet the code. If the structure underneath needs attention, take that as a sign to talk to the council.
In an Auckland Special Character Area, the Unitary Plan's assessment text says traditional materials such as corrugated steel sheet are generally appropriate, particularly where they match the original. That is a good reason to specify a corrugated profile, not a flat-pan or tile-effect one, when re-roofing a character house, and to ask the council before changing the roof form.
Sources
- Te Ara, Iron and steel: Corrugated iron
- Te Ara, Building materials: Roofing and glazing
- Building CodeHub, BRANZ Good Repair Guide: Profiled metal roofing (BK108)
- WorkSafe, Asbestos in the home quick guide (council-hosted copy)
- Building Act 2004, Schedule 1
- Health NZ, Lead-based paint
- Auckland Unitary Plan, D18 Special Character Areas Overlay