The Weatherboard Journal

Villas, bungalows and the timber houses of Auckland

Replacing weatherboards like-for-like on an old house

20 November 2026

Timber weatherboards are the skin of the Auckland villa, and they have a reputation for outlasting the people who nailed them on. BRANZ notes that even where maintenance has been less than ideal, boards have sometimes lasted more than a hundred years. Sooner or later, though, a board will fail, and the owner of an old house faces a small but real set of questions: what profile is this, where do I find a match, how do I cut one in, and do I need anyone's permission?

Find out why it failed first

A replacement board will fail again if the cause is still there. BRANZ says the most common cause of timber deterioration is failure of the protective paint coat, which lets the wood get and stay wet and eventually rot. Other causes it lists include boards split by incorrect fixing, such as double nailing, which restricts movement; nails that have popped or corroded; open joints at mitred corners or running joints; and corroded flashings and soakers.

BRANZ also gives a simple field test: if a screwdriver goes into the timber easily, the timber is rotten. Once you find rot, check the framing behind it, because if the rot has spread into the frame the job is bigger than one board. The guidance is in BRANZ's article on horizontal timber weatherboards.

Repairing the cause, whether that is a failed paint film, a blocked flashing or a leaking gutter, is as much part of the job as replacing the board.

Identify the profile

BRANZ says horizontal weatherboards are typically either bevel-back or rusticated. A bevel-back board has a thicker bottom edge, which reduces the risk of cupping, and its shape leaves gaps behind the board that help it dry. A rusticated board has a rebate along the bottom edge forming the lap over the board below, and its flat back sits closer to the framing, so drying behind it is more limited.

Old houses complicate matters. BRANZ points out that weatherboards on older houses are likely to vary in both profile and dimension, and the sizes are generally imperial rather than metric. Its illustrations show imperial examples such as a bevel-back of 140 mm by 21 mm and a larger one of 190 mm by 21 mm, while modern standard profiles are set out in NZS 3617:1979 and a BRANZ bulletin. The takeaway is to measure the actual board on your house, including cover width and thickness, rather than assuming a catalogue size will fit.

Match the timber

Te Ara records that the native timbers rimu and mataī took over from kauri as the supply of the latter ran down, and its 1966 encyclopaedia singles out mataī as a choice timber for flooring and weatherboards. Which species your house carries depends on its age and builder.

For matching, recycled timber is the natural first call. BRANZ, discussing floorboards, says demolition yards are the best source of extra boards in matching profiles, with the patina of age to suit. It is reasonable to ask a recycled-timber supplier about matching weatherboards in the same spirit, though the article is about floors.

New timber is allowed. BRANZ says the building code requires exterior wall cladding to have a minimum durability of 15 years, and lists the options that meet it: radiata pine must be treated to at least hazard class H3.1 and painted, or H3.2 if it is to go unpainted, while western red cedar, redwood and heart cypress need no preservative treatment and can be left uncoated or stain-finished. Fixings must have at least the same durability as the cladding.

Cutting in a new length

BRANZ describes replacing a rotted section of weatherboard without stripping the wall. In outline:

  1. Wedge up the board above, at the first stud past the damage, to lift it clear.
  2. Cut out the damaged section with a small saw, using angled cuts, taking care not to damage the wall underlay if there is one.
  3. Seal and prime all the cut ends.
  4. Cut a new insert to match the piece removed, slide it up into place under the wedged board, remove the wedges and nail it, fill the gaps and coat to match.

Nailing matters as much as cutting. BRANZ says every board is lapped and fixed with one nail per stud, which allows for the movement that moisture causes. Double nailing is the classic mistake and will crack boards later. The back face of a new board should be primed, and any exposed timber coated before it goes on.

If cracks or splits are small (no more than 2 mm wide and 400 mm long) and no water is entering, a flexible filler and paint will do. If water is entering the wall, the board should be replaced.

Do you need a building consent?

Usually not, but not always. Schedule 1 of the Building Act 2004 exempts repair and maintenance of a building product with a comparable product, and replacement with a comparable product in the same position. It excludes complete or substantial replacement of anything contributing to structure, and repair or replacement, other than maintenance, of something that has failed the code's durability requirements, for example by failing the external moisture requirements. A handful of boards cut in to match is comfortably repair. Re-cladding a whole wall in a different material is a different conversation, and a wall that has rotted because it was built without proper moisture protection is one to raise with the council before starting. Section 17 of the Act still requires the work to comply with the building code.

In an Auckland Special Character Area, restoration and repair are permitted by the Unitary Plan, but the plan's assessment text treats timber weatherboards as generally appropriate material, particularly where they match the original. Matching like with like is the route of least friction.

A caution about paint

Before about 1970, BRANZ says, most houses were painted with lead-based paint. Scraping and sanding old boards releases dust that can be a health risk, so close the windows and doors, catch debris on a groundsheet, seal it in heavy-duty bags and dispose of it as your council requires. A test kit will tell you what you are dealing with, since lead paint cannot be identified by appearance.

Sources

Also in the journal